Probate Q&A Series

How does a joint bank account with rights of survivorship affect what is part of the estate when there are unpaid debts? – North Carolina

Short Answer

In North Carolina, money in a true joint bank account with rights of survivorship usually passes directly to the surviving co-owner and is not a normal probate asset. However, the personal representative can reach the deceased owner’s share of the balance at death, if needed, to pay the year’s allowance, funeral and administration costs, and then unpaid creditors, but only after other probate assets are exhausted. Any remaining funds still belong to the surviving account owner, not the estate.

Understanding the Problem

The narrow question is: under North Carolina probate law, when there is a joint bank account with rights of survivorship and the estate has unpaid debts, what part of that account, if any, is treated as part of the estate for paying those debts? This comes up when a decedent dies with a joint survivorship account, limited probate assets, and creditors whose claims may exceed those probate assets. Personal representatives want to know whether they must pursue the surviving joint owner, or whether they can manage claims through the estate process, including allowances and reimbursement petitions, without separate litigation against the co-owner.

Apply the Law

Under North Carolina law, a properly created joint account with rights of survivorship passes outside the probate estate to the surviving joint owner. But statutes allow the personal representative to treat part of the decedent’s share of that account as available, if necessary, to pay certain estate obligations in a set order. This right to reach survivorship funds is limited in amount and timing and is used only when other personal property in the estate is not enough.

Key Requirements

  • Valid survivorship account: The account must be titled and documented as a joint account with rights of survivorship under North Carolina law, typically by a written agreement under right of survivorship statutes.
  • Decedent’s portion defined: Only the decedent’s deemed share of the unwithdrawn balance at death can be used, usually treated as an equal share among all joint tenants when contributions cannot be traced.
  • Estate insufficiency and claim priority: The personal representative may reach that share only after exhausting other probate personal assets, and then only to pay the year’s allowance, funeral costs, administration expenses, and remaining creditor and governmental claims, in that statutory order.

What the Statutes Say

Analysis

Apply the Rule to the Facts: In the described situation, the decedent died owning a joint bank account with rights of survivorship and an estate that likely cannot pay all debts. Under North Carolina law, the surviving co-owner ordinarily owns the account at death, but the personal representative can tap the decedent’s fractional share of the date-of-death balance to cover the year’s allowance, funeral and administration expenses, and then creditor and governmental claims, once other personal property has been used. By also using the year’s allowance and a reimbursement petition within the estate, the personal representative may resolve creditor claims without having to file a separate lawsuit directly against the surviving joint owner, so long as the statutory order of payment and limits on reaching the account are followed.

Process & Timing

  1. Who files: The personal representative (executor or administrator). Where: With the Clerk of Superior Court, Estates Division, in the North Carolina county where the estate is administered. What: Open the estate, inventory probate assets, and identify any survivorship accounts; file an Application and Assignment of Year’s Allowance (AOC-E-100) if a spouse or eligible child seeks an allowance. When: For deaths on or after March 1, 2024, a spouse’s year’s allowance must be claimed within six months after issuance of letters if a personal representative has been appointed.
  2. The personal representative evaluates creditor claims and available probate assets. If the estate is insufficient, the personal representative determines the decedent’s portion of the joint survivorship account based on the unwithdrawn balance at death and any contribution records, and then, as needed, seeks to recover only enough of that portion to cover priority items and allowed claims, often through estate accountings and, if necessary, a petition referencing the statutory right to recover survivorship funds.
  3. After paying the year’s allowance, funeral expenses, administration costs, and allowed creditor and governmental claims from probate assets and any recovered survivorship funds, the personal representative files required accountings with the Clerk. Any unused part of the decedent’s share of the joint account that was brought into the estate is then returned or paid to the surviving joint owner as required, and the estate is closed once the Clerk approves the final accounting.

Exceptions & Pitfalls

  • If the account is not properly documented as a survivorship account under North Carolina law, the decedent’s share may be treated as a normal probate asset rather than passing entirely to the survivor.
  • For older or non-statutory joint accounts, common law rules and contribution tracing can limit how much of the account is available for the decedent’s creditors, especially when the survivor contributed most of the funds.
  • Personal representatives who try to use survivorship funds before exhausting other personal property, or who ignore the priority of the year’s allowance, funeral and administration costs, risk objections from the Clerk and potential personal liability.
  • Failure to preserve records of the date-of-death balance and each owner’s contributions can make it harder to defend the estate’s position against creditors or the surviving joint owner.

Conclusion

In North Carolina, a joint bank account with rights of survivorship generally passes outside the probate estate to the surviving co-owner, but the estate can reach the decedent’s share of the unwithdrawn balance at death if necessary to pay the year’s allowance, funeral and administration expenses, and then unpaid creditors and governmental claims, after other personal assets are exhausted. The key next step is for the personal representative to open or continue the estate, document all assets and debts, and, within six months of receiving letters, file for any applicable year’s allowance so that creditor treatment and any use of survivorship funds follow the statutory order.

Talk to a Probate Attorney

If you are dealing with an insolvent North Carolina estate and joint bank accounts with rights of survivorship, our firm has experienced attorneys who can help you understand your options and timelines. Call us today at 919-341-7055.

Disclaimer: This article provides general information about North Carolina law based on the single question stated above. It is not legal advice for your specific situation and does not create an attorney-client relationship. Laws, procedures, and local practice can change and may vary by county. If you have a deadline, act promptly and speak with a licensed North Carolina attorney.