Guardianship Q&A Series

Do I need a new hearing in the new state even if the original state already approved the transfer? – North Carolina

Short Answer

Often, yes. Even if the original state issued a provisional order approving the transfer, North Carolina typically still requires a separate North Carolina court filing to accept the guardianship, and the court must hold a hearing if the court requests one or if an interested person asks for one. Once North Carolina issues its acceptance order and receives the other state’s final transfer order, North Carolina can issue updated authority (letters) and take over the case.

Understanding the Problem

In a North Carolina guardianship transfer, the key decision point is whether North Carolina must do anything in court after another state has already approved moving the guardianship. The question usually comes up when a guardian was appointed elsewhere, the ward later moved to North Carolina, and the guardian needs North Carolina to recognize the guardianship and issue North Carolina authority to act. The issue is not whether the other state “allowed” the move; it is whether the North Carolina clerk of superior court will accept jurisdiction and, if required, schedule a hearing before issuing North Carolina letters.

Apply the Law

North Carolina follows a two-court transfer process for an out-of-state guardianship to become a North Carolina guardianship. The transferring state typically enters a provisional transfer order first. Then the guardian must file a petition in North Carolina asking the clerk of superior court to accept the transferred guardianship and must attach a certified copy of the other state’s provisional transfer order. North Carolina may hold a hearing on the acceptance petition if the clerk orders one or if a required notice recipient (including the ward in many cases) requests one. If North Carolina grants the petition, it issues a provisional acceptance order. North Carolina then issues a final acceptance order after it receives the other state’s final transfer order, and the court must review within 90 days whether the guardianship needs changes to match North Carolina law.

Key Requirements

  • North Carolina acceptance petition: A petition must be filed in North Carolina to accept the transferred guardianship, and it must include a certified copy of the other state’s provisional transfer order.
  • Proper notice: Notice must go to the people who would be entitled to notice in both states, and it must be served the way North Carolina requires for these proceedings.
  • No disqualifying problem: North Carolina can deny acceptance if an objector proves the transfer is contrary to the ward’s interests or if the guardian is not eligible to serve under North Carolina rules.

What the Statutes Say

Analysis

Apply the Rule to the Facts: Here, a provisional transfer has already been started in the original state, and the goal is for North Carolina to accept jurisdiction and issue updated guardianship authority. Under North Carolina law, that usually still requires a North Carolina acceptance petition with a certified copy of the other state’s provisional transfer order, plus proper notice to required people. A new North Carolina hearing may be required if the clerk schedules one or if someone entitled to notice requests one, even if the original state already approved the transfer.

Process & Timing

  1. Who files: The currently appointed guardian. Where: The Clerk of Superior Court (Estates Division) in the appropriate North Carolina county. What: A petition asking North Carolina to accept the transferred guardianship, including a certified copy of the other state’s provisional transfer order. When: After the other state issues its provisional transfer order and as soon as practical after the ward’s move, especially if North Carolina letters are needed to deal with medical providers, housing, or finances.
  2. Notice and possible hearing: Required notice must be served in the manner North Carolina requires. The clerk may set a hearing, and the clerk must hold one if the clerk orders it or if the ward or another required notice recipient requests it.
  3. Provisional acceptance, then final acceptance: If the clerk grants the petition, North Carolina issues a provisional acceptance order. North Carolina then issues a final acceptance order after it receives the other state’s final transfer order. After the final acceptance order, the clerk must review within 90 days whether the guardianship should be modified to conform to North Carolina law.

Exceptions & Pitfalls

  • “Approved there” does not equal “effective here”: A provisional transfer order from the original state usually does not, by itself, create North Carolina authority. North Carolina acceptance (and then final acceptance) is what leads to North Carolina letters.
  • Notice problems cause delays: Transfer cases often stall because notice did not go to everyone entitled to notice in both states or because service did not follow North Carolina’s required method.
  • Objections can trigger a hearing: If someone objects and claims the transfer is not in the ward’s interests, the clerk may need a hearing to decide whether to accept the transfer.
  • Eligibility issues: North Carolina can deny acceptance if the proposed guardian is not eligible to serve under North Carolina rules, even if the guardian served in the original state.
  • Expect North Carolina “conformity” changes: Even after acceptance, North Carolina may require updates so the guardianship matches North Carolina law (for example, the scope of authority or administrative requirements), and the clerk must address that within 90 days after final acceptance.

Conclusion

In North Carolina, an out-of-state guardianship transfer usually requires a North Carolina acceptance case even if the original state already approved the transfer. The guardian generally must file a petition with the Clerk of Superior Court and include a certified copy of the other state’s provisional transfer order, provide proper notice, and be prepared for a hearing if the clerk or an interested person requests one. Next step: file the North Carolina petition to accept the transfer with the clerk in the appropriate county.

Talk to a Guardianship Attorney

If a guardianship started in another state and North Carolina needs to accept the transfer so updated letters can be issued, our firm has experienced attorneys who can help explain the steps, prepare the filings, and track the required notices and court orders. Call us today at (919) 341-7055.

Disclaimer: This article provides general information about North Carolina law based on the single question stated above. It is not legal advice for your specific situation and does not create an attorney-client relationship. Laws, procedures, and local practice can change and may vary by county. If you have a deadline, act promptly and speak with a licensed North Carolina attorney.